Reader Reviews

 
image

TEST OF TIME
BY JAYNE ANN KRENTZ, 1987
HARLEQUIN TEMPTATION #177
Reprinted 1995, $4.99, Mira Book; ISBN: 155166013X

Reviewed by: Danyelle Warden
Reviewed by: Mindy Lopez
Reviewed by: Beverly Kuhn

Katy Randall had grown up with the kind of social prestige & stable family life that Garrett Coltrane couldn't even imagine. Garrett had worked as a stable hand for Katy's father years earlier & had garnered Katy's adolescent attention even then. Garrett had gone on to establish for himself a reputation & consulting business that was now on par with Katy's family's. Their courtship had been calm & sweet. The couple shared many of the same outlooks, interest, & career goals, so it seemed natural that they would marry.

Katy's marriage to Garrett seems like a fairy tale love affair complete with the grand wedding celebration to rival Cinderella's. Garrett had been a complete gentleman throughout their courtship. However, Katy is stunned to realize that Garrett doesn't love her. Emotionally, Katy staggers under this knowledge. Garrett is baffled because they are a perfect match. Katy's demand for a divorce hits Garrett like a body blow. They negotiate a period of time to give their relationship a chance to grow within. Garrett convinces Katy that some time will help the resolve their problems. Katy is simply confused by Garrett's inability to love. As the novel progresses, Katy understands that Garrett does love her, he simply cannot identify the emotion.

This novel is quite reminiscent of TURNING TOWARDS HOME. The heroines both believe they have been mislead by their husbands, & in some respects they truly have been deceived. The heroines also share a love of horses, as well as a refusal to ride after horrible accidents. Both plots hinge on the necessity of the heroines overcoming their fears of riding in order to rescue someone beloved by their husbands. These strong heroines have successful careers in their chosen fields.

Likewise, the heroes share a few traits - pigheadedness, honor, beliefs that they know what is best for their wives, generosity, & the capacity to love deeply & forever. The heroes' careers both center around horses & ranching. Both men are strong, commanding hunks. What heroine could ask for better raw material to work with? They even come around to declaring their love for their wives!

Test of Time is well worth hunting for. The ultimate compliment that I can give a book is to rate it a "OSR - One sitting read." TOT met this criteria!

Danyelle Warden


Test of Time is a formula romance: well-bred, rich girl falls in love with poor, unsuitable stablehand who becomes financially successful; then returns to marry rich girl to gain respectability. And so we have Katy Randall and Garrett Coltrane in the lead roles.

Of course, no good love story would be devoid of misunderstandings between hero and heroine. On their wedding day, Katy overhears one of her guests speculate that Garrett married her for her background and breeding. Since Garrett has conducted a very proper courtship (no sexual overtures), this bit of gossip brings Katy's uncertainty and insecurity about Garrett's love for her to the forefront.

In the midst of their lovemaking on their wedding night, Katy tells Garrett that she loves him. His failure to respond with words of love makes Katy think that she has made a terrible mistake in marrying a man who doesn't love her. She confronts Garrett about it and asks him for a divorce. He tells her that he wants her in his house, his bed, and as a partner in his farm and ranch management consulting business. Since she is an expert in equine breeding programs, she will be an asset to his company. He appeals to her sense of fairness and strikes a bargain with her to stay with him for three months. She acquiesces thinking that a lot could happen in three months - she could make him fall in love with her.

There are secondary characters who help create more conflict between Katy and Garrett. The romantic tension is defused through love scenes that are tasteful but not clinical. As in all of Jayne Ann Krentz's books, the hero and heroine resolves their differences and live happily ever after (Hooray for happy endings!!).

This is a light, effortless read. JAK has the unerring ability to ferret out what her readers like and provide it superbly. I enjoyed this book very much and highly recommend it to romance fans.

Mindy Lopez


As a girl, she had worshipped Garrett Coltrane, her father's stable hand, from afar. But all too soon, the hard-working cowboy left the Randall's renowned Arabian farm and the rodeo circuit for a better life. Katy, badly injured in an accident and no longer willing to ride, returns to her father's farm after college to run the breeding operation. When Garrett returns a successful businessman, her childish infatuation matures into a woman's love. She readily accepts his proposal after a brief courtship believing he returns her feelings.

Garrett Coltrane married a woman he believed would be his partner . . . in business and in life.

Garrett's tragic and lonely youth was salvaged when Katy's father gave him a job. But he knew he wanted more. His determination and drive led to his successful consulting business. When he met up with Katy again, the quiet and reserved young woman appeared to be the perfect compliment to his burgeoning business and a natural mate for his chosen life.

Both got something they weren't expecting: Katy a husband who didn't love her, and Garrett a wife that was anything but docile. From the wedding night on, their wills clash as they struggle to find common ground and a salvation for the marriage.

Despite the old publication date, this novel still tells a wonderful story in vintage Krentz style. Both Katy and Garrett must come to terms with the wrong assumptions they made about the marriage and find a way to make things work. The reader cheers them on as they discover things about themselves and their spouse that offer hope.

My only complaint would be the initial lack of communication between the couple. Today, men and women should not rush into marriage without fully understanding their expectations and their depth of feeling. Communication is the key for a healthy relationship and a strong marriage. On occasion, I wanted to shout at Katy and Garrett to just speak and not rely on the other's ability to mind-read for understanding.

In all, an enjoyable read.

Beverly Kuhn


back to reviews

Return to the JAK Page